Before: Choosing between your celestial phase and your witchy phase, as if you have to and it can only be on or the other.
After: One crescent moon dangling from your left ear, one black witch hat from your right, and the sudden realization you never had to choose at all.
These mismatched earrings lean all the way into both sides of the witchy aesthetic: the mystical and the magical, the moon-gazer and the hat-wearer. The black hat with its purple ribbon and blue flower sits on one side; a warm gold shimmer crescent moon hangs on the other. Together they tell a small, complete story. Handmade in Canada and shipped to Canada & the US.
What You're Getting
- One mismatched pair: one black polymer clay witch hat earring and one gold shimmer crescent moon earring
- Witch hat pendant approximately 2cm wide with hand-sculpted purple ribbon, blue flower, and green leaf detail
- Crescent moon charm in warm gold shimmer polymer clay
- Both hang from 316 grade surgical steel leverback hooks — secure, stylish, and won't slip out
- Satin and gloss mixed finish across the pair
Also Available
Love the witch hat but want a different pairing? Find the mismatched witch hat and purple boot version in our shop. Just want the witch hats as a matching pair? Find them here. Want the moons as a matching pair? Look here.
A Note on Colour
Screen colours vary from device to device, so the black, gold, and purple you see in the photos may appear slightly different in person. I photograph everything in natural light, but if you have colour questions before ordering, just get in touch.
Where These Belong in Your Life
🧙On your ears at the Halloween party when someone looks twice and then says "wait ... is one a moon and one a hat?"
🧙On a Thursday in March when you're feeling celestial and nobody at work is going to stop you.
🧙Layered with a crescent moon necklace for a full witchy celestial moment.
🧙In a gift box for the friend who names her plants, talks to the moon, and owns at least one tarot deck.
These are the earrings for people who contain multitudes, and want both of them on their ears at the same time.
Questions? Use the contact form. We're always happy to help.
Choose options
Need help?
Frequently Asked Questions
Your Questions
Yes. Where mismatched options are available, you'll see them listed as a variation on the product page. Mix and match is actively encouraged.
Both the post and butterfly back are 316 grade surgical steel, a high-quality, widely used metal for earring findings. If you have a known metal allergy or sensitivity, please check with your doctor or dermatologist before wearing.
Polymer clay is lightweight and holds its shape well under normal everyday wear. Avoid dropping them on hard surfaces or storing them loose where they can get knocked around. Treat them gently and they'll last beautifully. A small jewellery dish or box is their best friend.
Yes. Leave a note at checkout and I'll include a handwritten card.
Shipping & Returns
All orders ship tracked through Chit Chats. Ontario orders typically arrive within 2–3 business days of shipping. You'll receive a tracking number as soon as your order is on its way.
Polymer clay pieces can be returned within 30 days of delivery, unworn, in original condition and packaging. Return shipping is the customer's responsibility and original shipping costs are non-refundable. If you're unsure about a colour or design, feel free to message me. I'm happy to answer questions before you commit.
Orders are made within 1–3 business days and ship from Canada every Monday and Thursday. Within Canada and to the US, you're typically looking at 5–10 business days once shipped. Feel free to message me before ordering if you're working to a deadline.